Anti-racist activist and librarian Juliette Hampton Morgan observed in a letter in 1952 about how the most polite and nicest individuals identifying as White were the biggest problems in addressing systemic racism. She wrote letters to local newspapers with critiques about segregation. Outside of the mistreatment of Black people during that time in history, what horrified her the most was the way in which White decency obstructed social change. Seven decades later, anti-racist educator Robin D'Angelo wrote a book, Nice Racism, to bring attention to the enduring facets of this activity.
DiAngelo analyses how individuals who identify as White deem themselves exempt from and inoculated against systemic racism, however, uniquely embody racist practices and interventions, including herself. She defines racism as a" collective racial bias that is backed by legal authority and institutional control", in which individuals and communities participate. DiAngelo distinguishes anti-racist strategies from the valued currency of White friendliness, stating that "niceness does not indicate a lack of racism nor is it a solution to racism. She added that a culture of niceness does not mean that racism is absent in the environment.
Robin DiAngelo wrote in her book about the racial illiteracy from proud liberal attendees who insinuate that they are beyond workshops on race, demonstrating how gradations in systemic racism is systemic racism itself. Janine Jones, an African-American philosopher, has also written about the efforts of White people to empathize with the difficulties of non-White people. She describes these individuals as praiseworthy for the concern they have for others, but asserts that they usually do not realize that their efforts are about helping others become more like themselves. Jones writes that unconscious level, they believe that their customs and beliefs are the best customs and beliefs for all. According to Jones, they offer their assistance from a position of condescension, because they do not see themselves as White, and do not understand how their Whiteness has come to deeply inform who and what they are.
These are all writers who have challenged and confronted the machinery of White progressiveness, how it works, and how effective and functional it can be, and impact those who are non-White. There are many liberal-sanctioned tactics and mechanisms that prioritize the insecurity, performance, and superiority of Whiteness over the needs and interests of those racially marginalized and oppressed groups and communities.
Defensive tropes are used against the critique of racial illiteracy -- such as adopting BIPOC children, interracial relationships, cross-racial friendships, or developing programs for children and adolescents in undeserved neighborhoods and communities. D'Angelo explores the ideology of White feminism as a product of racism, where there are dynamics employed by White women to the detriment, denigration, devaluation, and decentralization of BIPOC women in White-dominated spaces. Jones describes in her work that those who identify themselves as "goodwill Whites, administer programs, tools, resources, and interventions that confidently express to the world that what they offer is inherently "better", and individuals who receive their offerings are much more "better off" than those who are in racially-oppressed, poverty-stricken, under-funded environments and communities.
In these critiques of Whiteness, there was a sense of urgency and call to action to get the readers to consider how Whiteness shows up in areas of human activity: its illusions, promises, assumptions, and casual narratives of self-importance. It is in this space where we can collectively begin to remove the veil of Whiteness and see it what it truely is: an overinflation of the self based upon a mythology and lie that systemic racism has afforded itself. When individuals who identify as White interrogate, scrutinize, and deconstruct racial superiority they have inherited from their ancestors, they cannot do it. The perception is that being White is "neutral" in an otherwise racial world that they do not feel equipped with a voice.
DiAngelo challenges her White readers to ask why they think and believe that being nice is the best response to addressing racial inequity. This is a question that would lead one down this path towards knowledge and understanding of the self.
Having a shared identity is one of the most commonly requested factors for individuals who identify as Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC). Therapists who identify as BIPOC add value to our field. However, according to the American Psychological Association, only 12 percent of United States therapists identify with a racial/ethnic group. Everyone deserves a space where they are fully seen, heard, and able to achieve their personal and professional goals, so it’s critical that non-BIPOC therapists are knowledgeable, empathetic, and compassionate when addressing racism in therapy.
But what does this look like in practice? Non-BIPOC therapists must strengthen their cultural competency about racist and anti-racist practices, interventions, and methods to create safer and more informed spaces for BIPOC clients to discuss their lived experiences. As a Black therapist in private practice, I created a peer cohort where therapists like myself have accessible tools, resources, consultations, and training to address racism, race-based trauma, racial identity, and identity-based trauma and violence in a safe, supportive environment with both BIPOC and non-BIPOC therapists. In an ongoing process, we’re developing a culturally sensitive framework to help clinicians become more mindful of race, racism, and identity in the consulting room. Here are the ten points distilled from our conversations.
1) Commit to Ongoing Practice and Research
The first step is to address your own unconscious racial biases. Addressing racism goes beyond the belief that you’re not racist. It requires the humility, time, and commitment of energy and resources to pursue training, actively identify personal unconscious racial biases, and understand how your own social positioning may impact your relationship with clients. Consider listening to and reading books, articles, and podcasts. Attend in-person and online training, workshops, and consider consulting with and speaking with colleagues who identify as BIPOC or are racially-informed.
2) Learn Outside Therapy, Not During It
Self-education is important so that therapy can focus on the client's healing, rather than countertransference from your own racial identity development. Develop a personalized continuing education plan involving multiple methods to learn about systems of oppression and cultural norms, both inside and outside of your individual experiences. Educate yourself on the common misconceptions about police brutality, protests, and looting. Prioritize conversations with other white clinicians about anti-racism and anti-racist therapy, and learn about the differences between individual and systemic racism.
3) Get Curious about Your Client’s Unique Experiences
Making assumptions based on a client’s race or ethnicity can undermine their trust in the therapeutic process or cause them to feel stereotyped. In addition, asking a client to educate you about their culture centers you in the counseling process, when your focus should be on your client’s healing. Instead, it’s important to focus on your client as a unique human being with unique experiences. Questions like “How did that feel?” or “What were you thinking?” are ways of generating curiosity with your clients and understanding their unique experiences.
4) Be Aware of Microaggressions
Common mistakes that non-BIPOC therapists make include gaslighting, microaggressions, or lacking curiosity. Gaslighting is the act of questioning and dismissing clients’ unique experiences. Microaggressions are subtle intentional or unintentional actions and behaviors that denigrate or degrade clients, causing them to feel unsafe, attacked, or re-traumatized. Examples of gaslighting include questioning whether your client’s experiences related to their racial identities were actually racially driven. Microaggressions can include adopting or asking clients to adopt a colorblind or color-denial approach. It’s important that you gain self-awareness to know when you might be committing microaggressions, and learn how to counteract them. Look for workshops in this area or seek professional supervision to help.
5) Validate the Impact of Race and Racial Trauma
Racial colorblindness or racial color denial as it applies to therapy is the idea and belief that you see all clients equally, regardless of race. A colorblind approach prevents therapists from noticing how race impacts a client’s lived experiences and allows therapists to dismiss and minimize racial trauma, along with the client’s reality. It’s important to validate the client’s interpretation of their situation and recognize and consider the degree to which racism is embedded in our society. A few ways to address racism with clients include recognizing and validating the gravity of these experiences, identifying racism that clients experience as a form of racial trauma, and acknowledging that working through the pain of these experiences is a critical part of healing.
6) Acknowledge Differences and Express Your Commitment to Inclusivity
If you don’t understand the lived experiences and reality of someone who identifies as BIPOC, be transparent and open about your lack of understanding and cultural competence. Acknowledging cultural differences lets clients know about your openness to discussing race or racism. It’s an invitation to collaborate. Acknowledge and validate your client’s reactions to racism with statements such as, “Of course, your reaction and response to racism is completely understandable.” Acknowledge and validate that working through and processing these experiences is a critical part of healing and recovery. White therapists should tell their BIPOC clients something along the lines of, “While I may be a white person, I’m actively committed to creating an inclusive practice and a therapeutic space.” Acknowledge that every topic can be brought into the therapeutic process, which creates a safe and welcoming space for the reality and lived experiences that BIPOC people face on a daily basis. Topics related to race and racism are challenging to discuss, so it’s important to develop a sense of comfort in the discomfort.
7) Use Self-Disclosure to Bridge Social Distances
Multiple studies demonstrate the profound influence that white therapists’ self-disclosure can have in creating equal spaces for clients of color. This might include judicious sharing of personal information, such as your family life, which can make clients feel more trust and openness. Or, more generally, you can share your genuine reactions to your client's experiences of racism and oppression. However, there are instances where self-disclosure is not beneficial and may even worsen the cultural and social distance between you and your client. For example, non-BIPOC therapists may use the opportunity to self-disclose to placate themselves, putting their needs of ahead of their client’s. Self-disclosure should always be done in the interest of your client, not for any self-serving purposes. Carefully consider whether self-disclosure is an appropriate tool, and if relevant, introduce it to build a stronger bond and trust with your clients.
8) Respect Your Client’s Desire to See a Therapist with a Shared Identity
If your BIPOC client feels the therapeutic relationship with you isn’t a good fit or they want your help finding a therapist with a shared identity, make sure to respect their choice. Too often, therapists brush off or question a client’s desire to see a therapist with a shared identity. But if seeing a therapist of the same race will help your client in their healing journey, it’s important not to dismiss this.
9) Seek out Consultation and Supervision
Supervision, peer consultation, and personal therapy can be particularly helpful in identifying your biases, bringing awareness to countertransference, and helping you develop comfort discussing race. Many therapists who specialize in diversity and inclusion also offer formal supervision. Even if you’ve been practicing for years, supervision can be a useful tool to bring greater awareness to countertransference and ensure you’re growing as a therapist. If formal supervision is difficult to obtain or doesn’t feel like the right path for you right now, you can still do a lot of this work in peer consultation with non-BIPOC colleagues, by regularly discussing articles or books on the subject, for example.
10) Keep Doing the Work!
It’s important to recognize that this is challenging and ongoing work—but don’t give up! While it can be hard to hear a client say, “you don’t understand me,” keep investing your time and energy in understanding your own privileges and biases in order to assist BIPOC clients. Margaret Clausen, a clinical psychologist in Berkeley, California says, “Our privilege as white folks is that we can dip in and out of this work. I think of white therapists’ professional development regarding talking about race as an ongoing practice, one that involves further dialogue with other white therapists, and ongoing education."
This is hard work, and it can bring up feelings of guilt, shame, or defensiveness, so you’ll want to practice self-compassion and lean into the discomfort. After all, the only way through is through.
As issues of race and racism are being publicly explored, along with a more open dialogue around the experiences of BIPOC individuals, we therapists have a great opportunity to dig deeper into this work. This requires ongoing commitment and practice, but with the right tools and resources in place, we can begin creating more healing, inclusive spaces for all of our clients.
Various types of trauma can affect everyone differently and can have profound negative emotional, mental, and physical effects on the brain and body.
Unpacking racial trauma, or racial stress, which is the psychological, emotional and physiological symptoms that individuals experience after an exposure to a distressing or life-threatening experiences, by people, programs, policies, processes, and systems impacted by systemic oppression and privilege. There is room for opportunity to explore definitions of systemic racism, the psycho-biological effects of systemic racism, and interventions to overcome the short- and long-term effects of race-based stress.
Define systemic racism
Before unpacking the psychological impact of systemic racial oppression, and its effects on one’s mental and emotional well-being, it is important to understand the social and historical underpinnings of racism.
Early scientists and scholars in the 18th century defined racism with a belief that there was empirical evidence that existed, supported, and justified racial stratification, discrimination, and inferiority and superiority. While these beliefs are now considered insignificant, this racial conditioning has had long lasting effects on our society. The concept of racism has become systemic and is supported by a power system that believes that all people of color are inferior in every aspect of their lives: economics, education, entertainment, employment, law, religion, sex and sexuality, military, and healthcare, just to name a few. These power systems were structured and designed so that individuals who identify as White have greater access to privileges, benefits, and resources than those who do not identify as White.
It can be difficult and challenging for individuals to understand racism as systemic. Early pioneers of racial science invested in resources to prove race as a biological fact of life, while race has always been a social construction – which is a worldview informing shared assumptions about reality. Another way to understand race and racism as a systemic social construct is to observe how race and racism shapes the thoughts and behaviors of young children. It is rare that toddlers are discriminatory to another child based on their racial conditioning and programming. We witness the harmonious play and interaction between children with the exception of age-appropriate behaviors such as tantrums and disagreements. But as children grow up and are influenced by messages from their families, friends, culture, media, and societal norms, we see thoughts, feelings, and behaviors about race and identity begin to emerge and develop over time. Sometimes, those thoughts, feelings, and behaviors hold the belief of White superiority over Black individuals.
The effects of race-based stress
Traumatic experiences can be real or perceived, directly experienced or witnessed, interpersonal, or systemic. And the effects of trauma can be inherited, transferred within communities, and passed down across generations. Individuals and groups who experience trauma as pervasive and covert, particularly those who have experienced racial trauma, can find it difficult to recognize the impact, understand its consequences, and overcome short- and long-term effects.
Dr. Joy DeGruy coined the term Post-Traumatic Slave Syndrome (PTSS) in her book, “Post Traumatic Slave Syndrome: America’s Legacy of Enduring Injury and Healing,” which describes historical and inter-generational trauma as a result of systemic oppression and slavery impacting people of African descent in America. Systemic racism continues to perpetuate harm, injury, and violence as evidenced by the recent casualties of Black men, women and children by law enforcement, which is controlled and operated by oppressive power systems.
PTSS shares similar symptoms with the commonly known diagnosis of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder including intrusive or recurrent memories, traumatic nightmares, dissociative reactions, difficulty concentrating, feeling jumpy, being easily angered, and feelings of hopelessness and depression. For those who were brought to the Americas from Africa, they were exposed to a lifetime of traumas, which were never addressed, nor did the traumas ever stop. African Americans have continued to experience traumas similar to those who were enslaved in history through centuries of systemic oppression and the belief that Whiteness is superior to Blackness.
The effects of PTSS and other race-based stressors have increased unemployment rates, destroyed families, interrupted ethnic and cultural values around identity and relationships, and affected short- and long-term goals. Getting professional support to address the threats of continuing assaults means that we must develop healthy coping mechanisms to support and heal ourselves, our families, and our communities from the insidious and corrosive effects of systemic racism.
Overcome the effects of race-based stress
The first step in healing from the effects of race-based stress or racial trauma is to affirm and validate one’s own reality and lived experiences. Become educated about people in history who suffered abuse and a lifetime of traumas, but still managed to rise and overcome adversity. By understanding where we’ve come from, we can identify strengths and build upon them.
From here, individuals and groups identifying as BIPOC can integrate solutions and strategies into their everyday life, including, but not limited to:
Know you are not alone
Systemic racism is a pervasive, corrosive, and harmful experience that has affected our culture and society for centuries, particularly impacting individuals and groups that have been historically marginalized and oppressed. Since the injuries resulting from inter-generational trauma occurred on multiple levels, we must heal in multiple ways and on multiple levels. Everyone is faced with carrying on our lives in such a way that we are able to manage life’s daily stressors and enjoy the benefits of living a happy and healthy life. Seeking help from a trauma-informed culturally competent therapist can assist with managing and overcoming the effects of race-based stress. Trauma-informed individual therapy and group therapy are beneficial avenues to explore concerns, process experiences, and take the necessary steps to heal.
If you’re struggling to process your life experiences around your identity or feel like no one else understands you, know that you are not alone. Connect with a professional experienced in addressing and overcoming race-based stress and its traumatic effects. We tailor a therapeutic process to meet your needs and offer a foundation of trauma-informed, collaborative, multicultural, culturally-sensitive, and mindfulness practices.